The 2024 MLB Draft class is already making waves in the 2026 baseball season, with seven of the first nine picks having debuted and significantly contributed to their teams’ successes. This early impact raises the question of whether this draft class could be one of the best in history. If a re-draft were held today, who would claim the top spot?
In a recent episode of Baseball Bar-B-Cast, hosts Jake Mintz and Jordan Shusterman delved into the top 20 selections from the much-talked-about 2024 draft. They conducted a re-draft based on the recent performances of these players, speculating whether the Cleveland Guardians would still select Travis Bazzana first overall, or if they would lean towards Sacramento A’s slugger Nick Kurtz or St. Louis Cardinals shortstop JJ Wetherholt instead.
Shifting focus, the discussion turned to Rafael Devers, who expressed his dissatisfaction with San Francisco Giants manager Tony Vitello after being pinch-run for during a crucial moment. The hosts debated whether Devers had a valid reason to be upset about the decision.
The episode also highlighted Bryce Harper’s achievement in hitting for the cycle, a milestone that brought controversy due to a triple he earned during the game, marking the first cycle of his career with the Philadelphia Phillies. Additionally, the hosts reviewed the Detroit Tigers’ critical stretch in the postseason race and recapped all the other series from the weekend.
With engaging insights and lively banter, Mintz and Shusterman kept listeners entertained while analyzing the latest happenings in the MLB.
Note: This recap is an independently written summary based on publicly available reporting.
LAA
BAL
OAK
CIN
NYM
CLE
PIT
MIL
TOR
CHC
DET
SEA
WSH
PHI
CHW
BOS
MIA
ATL
MIN
KC
SD
ARI
NYY
TEX
COL
STL
HOU
LAD
TB
SF