Diamondbacks Face Closer Dilemma Ahead of New Season

As the Diamondbacks gear up for the upcoming season, they find themselves once again without a designated closer. Strengthening the bullpen was a top priority during the offseason, especially after the challenges faced in 2025. However, it seems that the focus has shifted to other areas rather than solidifying the closer position. With A.J. Puk and Justin Martinez expected to return in the first half of the season, it’s understandable why the team hasn’t made a significant investment in a closer. Yet, fans were likely hoping for more than the offseason signings of Taylor Clarke and Paul Sewald, no disrespect to either player.

Manager Torey Lovullo appears poised to employ match-ups for save opportunities, but reports suggest that Paul Sewald could emerge as the primary option, particularly following an uptick in his velocity this spring. Despite the buzz surrounding him, Sewald has downplayed any expectations, stating on Arizona Sports 98.7, “They’ll pitch me when they decide to pitch me.” This sentiment may give fans pause, as Sewald had a rocky experience last season. He began 2024 as the closer but lost the role after a dismal July, where he posted a 10.80 ERA, went 0-2, and recorded four blown saves. Given that history, it’s not surprising that some might view the prospect of reinstating him as a case of repeating past mistakes.

However, this survey aims to gauge not just what fans believe the team will do, but what they believe should be done. Beyond Sewald, there are several candidates for the closer role, each with their own uncertainties. Kevin Ginkel, for instance, has experience with 16 career saves but struggled last season, finishing with a 7.84 ERA. The lack of a clear standout candidate opens the door for even non-roster invitees like Jonathan Loáisiga to be considered. Last year, the team found success with non-roster invitee Shelby Miller, who ended up leading the squad in saves.

Below is a list of potential candidates for the closer position. Which player would you prefer to see take on this crucial role for the Diamondbacks until Puk and Martinez return? Alternatively, if you believe in a “closer by committee” approach, feel free to select “other.” As always, your thoughts are welcome in the comments below.

Note: This recap is an independently written summary based on publicly available reporting.