Marcus Semien Returns but Sits as Brett Baty Shines in Mets’ Victory

Marcus Semien made his return from the 10-day injured list on Thursday, just in time for the New York Mets’ 4-1 victory over the Philadelphia Phillies, but surprisingly, he was not in the lineup. This decision by interim manager Andy Green highlights the struggles Semien has faced in his first season with the Mets, leading to an opportunity for Brett Baty to shine against Philadelphia right-hander Aaron Nola.

Baty seized the moment, contributing significantly with two hits, including a home run. “When my name is called, I’ll be ready,” Semien remarked before the game. “I’m ready to play every single day. That’s what I told Andy.” Despite Semien’s eagerness, Green indicated that the team wanted to ensure Semien had a full workout day before starting him, as he did not participate in any minor league rehab games during the break.

Green also mentioned that Semien is expected to be back in the lineup on Saturday when the Mets face lefty Jesús Luzardo. “He’ll figure prominently in our mix going forward,” Green said, underscoring Semien’s importance in the team’s plans despite his recent struggles.

Semien, who has been a key player in the Mets’ offseason overhaul initiated by president of baseball operations David Stearns, was sidelined since June 24 due to a left hip flexor strain. His return is eagerly anticipated, especially as the veteran second baseman has been enduring the worst season of his 14-year career, marked by declining offensive performance and below-average defense at second base.

Baty’s versatility as a player is a significant asset, as he can play both second and third base, with Green hinting at the possibility of using him at first base as well. “This is who he is as a hitter and what he can do,” Green noted, praising Baty’s recent hot streak. “He presents a lot of defensive versatility and he’s showing the pop in his bat we believe he has.”

Reflecting on his season, Baty acknowledged his struggles, stating, “I don’t think it’s been good at all. I hold myself to a way higher standard than the way I’ve been playing. I think the last two or so weeks have been the kind of player I am: hitting the ball hard and playing good defense. That’s all I can really control.”

To accommodate Semien’s return, Zack Short was designated for assignment after starting the last three games before the break at second base. Short’s playing time had increased partly due to Bo Bichette’s right ankle soreness, but with Bichette back in the lineup at third base on Thursday, Baty was positioned at second, highlighting the strategic adjustments the Mets are making as they navigate the season.

Note: This recap is an independently written summary based on publicly available reporting.