An Early Morning Analysis of the Giants’ Quarterback Dilemma

Before Daniel Jones’ $23 million injury assurance for the 2025 season could potentially complicate matters, the New York Giants were already contemplating their quarterback options. This consideration was brought to light on an upcoming Sunday, when the Giants were set to face a quarterback they had previously considered drafting.

Considering a New Draft Choice

On HBO’s “Hard Knocks” during the offseason, a conversation between Giants’ general manager Joe Schoen and coach Brian Daboll gave fans a glimpse into their consideration for top 2024 draft pick, Jayden Daniels. Daniels, a Heisman Trophy-winning quarterback from LSU, was a contender for a trade-up for the Giants, but they couldn’t secure the No. 2 slot.

The Question of Daniel Jones

The Giants also have an impending decision to make about Jones, who has a $23 million injury guarantee for 2025 that becomes fully assured if he suffers an injury and fails a physical in the offseason. This scenario has prompted other NFL teams to sideline their quarterbacks to avoid activating injury guarantees.

A Trend in the NFL

Cases in point include the Denver Broncos, who sidelined Russell Wilson prior to a possible injury that could have triggered a $37 million guarantee for 2024. Wilson has since signed with the Steelers. Similarly, the Raiders benched Jimmy Garoppolo to bypass an injury that might have guaranteed an additional $11.25 million due this season.

Giants’ Dilemma with Jones

Although the Giants have yet to reach this juncture with Jones, his performance could necessitate a similar decision. Jones’ struggles were evident in the Giants’ season opener against the Vikings, where he threw two interceptions and completed only slightly over half his passes. Despite a shaky start, coach Daboll endorsed Jones as the Giants’ primary quarterback, and Jones maintained that he looked forward to proving his worth on the field.

The Road Ahead for the Giants

The Giants, who have a 1-6 record in the seven games Jones has started since his four-year, $160 million contract, will have to consider their quarterback options if his performance doesn’t improve. The team’s future at the quarterback position remains a topic of intense scrutiny and speculation, making every game a critical juncture in their decision-making process.