Pittsburgh Penguins: Key Offseason Decisions for 2026-27 Roster

The Pittsburgh Penguins are entering a pivotal offseason, one that holds the potential to reshape their roster for the 2026-27 season. Fresh off a playoff run that exceeded expectations, the franchise faces crucial decisions this summer, particularly concerning their mix of restricted and unrestricted free agents. General Manager Kyle Dubas has strategically amassed assets and draft capital, signaling a likely shift towards integrating younger talent into the lineup.

Among the players deserving of a new contract is Yegor Chinakhov. The young winger expressed his desire to remain in Pittsburgh during locker cleanout day, stating he wants to be “part of the organization for a long time.” His impressive tally of 18 goals and 36 points in just 43 games solidifies his case for a multi-year deal—likely in the range of three years at $4.5 million per season—as he is viewed as a key component of the Penguins’ future.

On the other hand, the Penguins must consider the future of goaltender Arturs Silovs. His remarkable .939 save percentage in the playoffs showcased his potential as a clutch performer, and his playoff heroics were pivotal in the Penguins’ comeback against the Philadelphia Flyers. Silovs’ ability to elevate his game when it matters most makes him a valuable asset, and it’s reasonable to expect him to be part of the goaltending tandem next season alongside Sergei Murashov.

Forward Noel Acciari had a solid season, contributing 13 goals and 25 points as part of a tenacious fourth line. However, at 34 years old, bringing him back could hinder the development of younger players like Avery Hayes and Tristan Broz, who are ready for more ice time. Thus, it might be prudent for the Penguins to part ways with Acciari to allow these prospects the opportunity they deserve.

Defenseman Connor Clifton showed flashes of potential towards the end of the season, but his performance did not warrant a new contract, especially with the Penguins looking to clear space for younger players like Harrison Brunicke. Clifton’s physical play is an asset, but the organization may opt for fresh talent on the blue line, making his return unlikely.

Meanwhile, forward Connor Dewar had a career year, posting highs in both goals (14) and points (30). Despite a second-half slump, Dewar’s contributions to the fourth line alongside Blake Lizotte have solidified his standing within the team. The Penguins are likely to retain him, as he brings youth and energy to their depth chart.

Avery Hayes, known for his positive influence in the locker room, may not be retained due to limited playing time and age-related concerns. At 33, his contributions have diminished, making his position on the roster more precarious.

One of the most discussed figures is Evgeni Malkin, who, despite turning 40 next season, demonstrated he still possesses the skill to be a point-per-game player. Malkin’s willingness to play wing and his desire for “one more year” suggest that extending his contract could be beneficial for both the player and the organization. Given his history and current performance, it would be surprising if the Penguins do not bring him back for at least one more season.

Anthony Mantha, who led the Penguins with 33 goals this season, may be looking for a lucrative contract following his performance. However, committing long-term to a 31-year-old with injury history could be risky. The franchise might weigh their options carefully before deciding whether to keep him or allow him to seek opportunities elsewhere.

Defensively, Markus Shea had a career year with six goals and 35 points, and his plus-30 rating made him a standout on the blue line. He is likely due for a pay raise, but the Penguins may also look to upgrade their defensive corps, making his future uncertain. Shea’s potential extension could hinge on whether the team can strike a deal before exploring other options.

Another name to watch is Dmitri Solovyov, who could serve as a versatile depth option. At just 26, he has room for growth and could be retained if the Penguins decide to keep him around. However, if another team presents an opportunity for more playing time, he may choose to move on.

The goaltending landscape in Pittsburgh is evolving, with the emergence of Silovs and the possibility of Murashov becoming a full-time NHLer. While Casey DeSmith has been a reliable presence, the success of Silovs during the playoffs may influence the team’s decision to move forward without him. Skinner’s strong performance and positive presence in the locker room make him a candidate for a mentoring role, but he may seek more playing time elsewhere.

As the Penguins navigate this offseason, the decisions they make will undoubtedly shape the future of the franchise. With a blend of experience and youth, the organization is poised to take the next step toward contending in the coming seasons.

Note: This recap is an independently written summary based on publicly available reporting.