Montembeault Seeks Stability in Canadiens’ Goaltending Plans

Montreal Canadiens goaltender Samuel Montembeault is making his intentions clear as he heads into a pivotal contract year: he has no interest in being part of a goaltending carousel this season. After a challenging previous season, Montembeault, 29, understands the importance of a strong performance to secure his future in the NHL. His desire for stability comes at a crucial time, as he looks to rebound from struggles that saw him sidelined last year.

General Manager Kent Hughes reassured Montembeault during last season’s struggles, reminding him that one off year doesn’t define a goaltender’s career. He referenced Jeremy Swayman, who turned a rough patch into a Vezina Trophy nomination. However, the context is different; Swayman had the financial security of a contract when he faced his downturn. Montembeault’s aspirations are clear: he wants to prove his worth and ideally do so in Montreal.

Montembeault has been a reliable teammate and has already navigated the ups and downs of goaltending partnerships, having shared the net with Jake Allen and Cayden Primeau, then again with Jakub Dobes and Jacob Fowler. With Dobes securing a three-year contract extension that kicks in during the 2027-28 season, Montembeault recognizes the competition for the backup role. If he can secure that position, it would provide him a platform to demonstrate his capabilities to the rest of the league. Given that he won’t receive another extension from the Canadiens, playing in a less favorable role could hinder his chances of convincing other teams of his potential.

As the offseason continues, Montembeault remains in limbo while other goaltenders have found new homes. Hughes is reluctant to sell low on Montembeault, whose value has dipped since the Canadiens claimed him off waivers in 2021 as a stopgap for Carey Price’s injuries. The current situation is stark: Montembeault’s stock is at a low point, and the Canadiens are in no rush to part ways unless they can secure a favorable deal.

There are still teams struggling with their goaltending situations. The Edmonton Oilers are relying on often-injured veteran Frederik Andersen, backed by Tristan Jarry, who had a lackluster season. Although they added Devon Levi as an insurance option, his NHL performance remains unproven. Time is running short for the Oilers to build a competitive roster around superstar Connor McDavid, who will be a UFA in two seasons.

The Winnipeg Jets have also been in the conversation regarding Connor Hellebuyck’s potential trade. If they move him, Montembeault could find himself in the mix, especially with their current backup, Stuart Skinner, not having impressive recent statistics. Meanwhile, the New Jersey Devils are juggling three goaltenders—Jake Allen, Nico Dawes, and David Rittich—none of whom have proven to be a reliable starter. Allen, who has excelled in a backup role, now appears to be the leading choice.

While there’s a chance Fowler could be sent to the AHL, leaving Montembeault and Dobes in Montreal, many question whether this environment is conducive to Montembeault’s resurgence. He acknowledged that he placed excessive pressure on himself last season, leading to his struggles. With the scrutiny that comes with playing in Montreal, the challenge of overcoming last year’s issues looms large. Can he find a way to thrive under such pressure, or would a fresh start in a different market serve him better?

Follow Karine on X @KarineHains, Bluesky @karinehains.bsky.social, and Threads @karinehains.

Note: This recap is an independently written summary based on publicly available reporting.